According to proponents of the Coriolis Effect, in the Northern Hemisphere wind systems rotate counter-clockwise, and in the Southern Hemisphere wind systems will rotate clockwise. This is provided as evidence of the Coriolis Effect, and therefore, as evidence of the diurnal motion of the earth. We find, however, that the permanent wind and water systems of the earth rotate in a contradictory manner to what is alleged by the Coriolis Effect. It is mainly the tropical cyclones which originate from certain patterns of wind currents near the equator that rotate with the correct direction.
Dr. Anantha Aiyyer of NC State University explains that, due to the rotation of the earth, systems should rotate counter-clockwise in the Northern Hemisphere and clockwise in the Southern Hemisphere.
“ Q: Why do hurricanes go counterclockwise in the northern hemisphere and clockwise in the southern hemisphere?
A: You can think of a hurricane as a spinning column of air that stretches from sea-level up to about 45,000 feet. Over much of this depth, air flows counter-clockwise in the northern hemisphere and clockwise in the southern hemisphere. To understand why, let’s consider the rotation of the earth. We know that the earth spins along an invisible axis from west to east. But if we look at it differently, something interesting jumps out. Imagine you are hovering above one of the poles and are looking down at the earth. Pick the North Pole and do this thought experiment. In what sense is the earth rotating? Counterclockwise. Now fly to the South Pole and look at the earth and notice its rotation. It will help to use a spinning tennis or basketball to visualize this. It now appears to spin clockwise.
We note that hurricanes spin in the same direction as the earth’s hemisphere (as viewed from the poles) they are located in. This is not a coincidence. The atmosphere is attached to the spinning earth and as a result every column of air is also spinning. When that inherent spin is concentrated (this happens when air convergences into an area) we get rotating storms like hurricanes. As the sense of rotation is opposite in the two hemispheres, this leads to oppositely spinning hurricanes. ”
The National Geographic issues the same depiction:
“ The Coriolis effect makes wind systems twist counter-clockwise in the Northern Hemisphere and clockwise in the Southern Hemisphere. ”
- 1 Prevailing Wind and Ocean Systems
- 2 Hurricanes and Tropical Cyclones
- 2.1 Counter-Rotating Vortexes
- 2.2 Crossing the Equator
- 2.3 Origin of Hurricanes
- 2.4 Hurricane Life Cycle
- 2.5 Currents at the Equator
- 3 Addendum
Prevailing Wind and Ocean Systems
"Prevailing Winds" and "Trade Winds" are the world's large permanent wind systems which put the ocean systems into motion. When we look at the permanent wind and ocean systems of the world, we find the counter-clockwise rule of the Northern Hemisphere and the clockwise rule of the Southern Hemisphere to be untrue. Earth's large permanent wind and ocean systems are rotating in a manner contrary to the alleged Coriolis Effect.
“ Observations indicate that surface currents are chiefly wind-driven. ”
Atmosphere-Ocean Dynamics, Volume 30 on p.516 pp.2 tells us:
“ There is little doubt that the major surface currents are predominantly wind-driven ”
Prevailing Currents of the Pacific
Prevailing Currents of the Pacific (Click for bigger)
Map from Atlas of World Maps, United States Army Service Forces, Army Specialized Training Division. Army Service Forces Manual M-101 (1943).
Prevailing Winds (Generalized)
Below we find a world map which shows a generalized pattern of the wind rotation. One should note that the rotations seen are clockwise in the Northern Hemisphere and counter-clockwise in the Southern Hemisphere, which is opposite from the "Coriolis Effect".
North Pole Gyre
In fact, at the North Pole, where the Coriolis Effect is supposedly the greatest, we find a gyre that is traveling directly through the North Pole and rotating in a clockwise direction, opposite from the Coriolis Effect.
- —Moby-Duck: The True Story of 28,800 Bath Toys Lost at Sea by Donovan Hohn
- —National Snow & Ice Data Center (Archive)
“ For many years, geologists have used the Coriolis effect to suggest that right banks of rivers will tend to erode more rapidly than left banks in the Northern Hemisphere; this has been proven not to be true. ”
North Carolina's Climate Office says:
“ Tornadoes are not impacted by the Coriolis Effect because they are so small in scale and short in duration. ”
American Scientist says:
“ A tornado, however, has a high horizontal velocity (meaning it spins really fast) and a relatively small size. Its Rossby number is large. The Earth’s rotation should not affect the way tornadoes spin. And in fact you can see tornadoes rotating in counterclockwise and clockwise directions in either hemisphere. ”
Hurricanes and Tropical Cyclones
Coriolis Effect proponents mainly point to the rotation of hurricanes and other tropical cyclones. In the Northern Hemisphere tropical cyclones rotate counter-clockwise, and in the Southern Hemisphere tropical cyclones rotate clockwise, true to the Coriolis Effect. While researching this claim, we find that these rotational directions are generally true for the hurricanes and tropical cyclones.
Unlike the permanent wind and water systems of the earth, however, the hurricanes and tropical cyclones are special and temporary weather systems which have an average lifespan of about 9 days. The directions of rotation of these temporary systems are entirely explainable with known and existing phenomena called Kelvin Waves which do not require the Coriolis Effect. Indeed, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) has verified Kelvin Waves to occur during cyclone development, and now uses them in their early warning systems.
To explain why the hurricanes rotate oppositely from each other we point to the fact that the Hurricanes and other tropical cyclones develop near the equator, and that at the equator there exists a strong wind current called the Equatorial Counter Current, which is a strong permanent easterly-flowing wind current. This Counter Current runs in an opposite direction to westerly-flowing currents that are immediately North and South of it. Since the atmosphere is generally characterized as a fluid, we can imagine this as a water current which moves against the flow of the waters around it.
We look to the following videos, where friction in water creates oppositely rotating vortexes:
The above videos show the creation of counter-rotating vortexes when the water is disturbed by plates or spoons.
The same general phenomena seen in the fluids of water in the above videos are occurring with the fluids of the air near the equator. When comparing the direction plate and spoon across the water with the direction of vortex rotation to the direction of the Equatorial Counter Current and the directions of vortex rotation in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres, we find that the directions match up. A "Coriolis Effect" is not needed to describe the rotational direction of these systems.
Kelvin Wave Pattern (Water)
The oppositely rotating vortexes in the videos above are caused by the Kelvin Wave Pattern. When an object disturbs water it will leave a wake in its path, which fans out and curves in opposite directions.
Along these oppositely curving patterns water rushes towards the body to fill in the gap left by the disturbance. The curves of this moving water system themselves also flow to follow the direction of the body. If the boat were traveling eastwards the flow of the water on the curved paths would be traveling counter-clockwise to the north of the boat and clockwise to the south of the boat, like the "Coriolis Effect".
As demonstration of these curving patterns, we find a video of a model toy boat making curved wakes behind it. Note that the boat leaves behind curved paths, and that these paths follow the boat once it passes, indicating the direction of flow.
The University of British Columbia provides a technical assessment of the Kelvin Wave Pattern on water (Archive)
Kelvin-Rossby Wave Pattern (Atmospheric)
A 2000 study describes the creation of Kelvin wave patterns created by Rossby wind current collisions over equatorial "warm pools":
Abstract: “ Deep convection over the western tropical Pacific warm pool is analyzed in terms of its relation to the atmospheric Kelvin–Rossby wave, which dominates the large-scale flow during the austral summer. The study uses Doppler radar data collected by aircraft and ship radars during different time periods in the Tropical Ocean Global Atmosphere Coupled Ocean–Atmosphere Response Experiment to characterize the mesoscale circulations of organized convective cloud systems occurring throughout the season. ”
Diagram Caption: “ FIG. 1. Zonally asymmetric circulation produced by a deep heating anomaly over the equator (stippled). (a) Plan view of surface motion. (b) Streamlines in a vertical cross section over the equator. (From Gill 1980 as shown by Salby 1996.) ”
According to the above, when wind currents collide over "warm pools" at the equator counter-rotating wind patterns are created.
We see that in the diagram the northern system is rotating counter-clockwise while the southern system rotates clockwise, just as was depicted in the premise.
The system in the diagram above is described as having a strong westerly core: “ The deep convection was concentrated both in the strong westerly core of the system and in the gyres. ”
Further, we see in the illustration that these gyres are rotating around centers of low pressure, just as the hurricanes and tropical cyclones do. The National Geographic says (Archive): “ Hurricanes spin around a low-pressure center known as the “eye.” Sinking air makes this 20- to 30-mile-wide (32- to 48-kilometer-wide) area notoriously calm. But the eye is surrounded by a circular “eye wall” that hosts the storm’s strongest winds and rain. ”
Counter Current Activity Correlation
The following is a study which associates curious activity in eastwardly flowing Equatorial Counter Current, also known as the North Equatorial Counter Current, with the development of hurricanes.
Abstract: “ An analysis of archived data from the NEMO 1/12th degree global ocean model shows the importance of the North Equatorial Counter Current (NECC) in the development of the strong 1982–1983 and 1997–1998 El Niños. ”
Text: “ The forcing fields show that periods with strong westerly winds occurred at the Equator during the development of both the two strong El Niños studied and the warm pool event ”
Hence, we find that strong westerly winds at the equator, in conjunction with the warm pool event, was associated with the development of the El Niño hurricanes.
Atmospheric Kelvin Waves Confirmed in Development of Hurricanes
In 2015 meteorologists confirmed the influence of atmospheric Kelvin Waves in the development of tropical cyclones.
“ A new study by Carl Schreck III of the North Carolina Institute for Climate Studies and North Carolina State University provides important insights into the way long-lived tropical weather patterns known as Kelvin waves influence the development of tropical cyclones. The findings are already being used by NOAA’s Climate Prediction Center and National Hurricane Center in forecasting tropical storm development.
Atmospheric Kelvin waves are tropical rainfall systems accompanied by distinctive westerly and easterly wind patterns. These waves move eastward around the Earth and can circumnavigate the tropics over the course of a month. ”
Q. If the tropical cyclones are created by Kelvin Waves, then why don't we ever see twin cyclones?
A. According to the University Corporation for Atmospheric Research they often do come in pairs. The following study (Archive p.47) has images of twin cyclones in development via Kelvin Waves. From the Summary section of the document we see infrared weather imagery from "satellite" data:
“ On 4 May 2002, a linear formation of convection became a Kelvin wave straddling the equator and propagating eastward. ”
“ Consequently, the convection from the active Kelvin wave generated twin vortices on 6 to 7 May 2002. These represented a pair of westward-moving equatorial Rossby waves. ”
“ These equatorial Rossby waves provided the circulations from which two additional tropical cyclones developed: TC2B and Tropical Cyclone Errol. These are shown as they were on 10 May 2002 at 18 UTC, below. ”
Crossing the Equator
Coriolis Effect proponents further assert that the cyclones do not cross over the equator into the opposing hemisphere. Although we have found articles of instances where cyclones have crossed for a short time before dying out, we accept the rarity and point out the following:
- At the equator exists a strong and permanent easterly-flowing current called the Equatorial Counter Current, which is bordered on the North and South by permanent westerly-flowing currents called the Northern and Southern Equatorial currents. Such a hurricane would need to defeat these currents in order to make it across.
- Hurricanes are created by these topical wind currents, and are sent spiraling Northward or Southward away from the tropical regions of the equator to cause havoc towards temperate regions of the North or South.
- Hurricanes have relatively short lives with an average of about 9 days.
The above points make it unreasonable for a hurricane to return to the equator and cross to the other side.
Hurricanes do not move around randomly, but are steered by high altitude wind currents:
“ Hurricanes are "steered" by the prevailing wind currents that surround the storm from the surface to 50,000 feet or more. The storms move in the direction of these currents and with their average speed. ”
Origin of Hurricanes
Where Are Hurricanes Formed?
“ Hurricanes are the most violent storms on Earth. They form near the equator over warm ocean waters. ”
Hurricane Path Map
150 years of tropical cyclone tracks through 2006
“ The graphic above clearly reveals that hurricanes (Atlantic basin, E. Pacific), typhoons (W. Pacific), and cyclones (Indian Ocean, Australia) rarely if ever form between 5 deg North and 5 deg South latitudes, respectively. ”
Hurricane Life Cycle
“ Most hurricanes follow a similar cycle of development, called a hurricane life cycle. These life cycles may run their course in as little as a day or last as long as a month. The longest-lasting tropical cyclone ever observed was Hurricane/Typhoon John, which existed for 31 days as it traveled a 13,000 km (8,100 mi) path from the eastern Pacific to the western Pacific and back to the central Pacific. There have also been many tropical cyclones that remained at hurricane intensity for 12 hours or less, including the Atlantic hurricane, Ernesto, in 2006. ”
“ "Average life of a hurricane, determined by time and place of origin and rate of forward movement, is nine days." (TCMC, 1976). ”
“ Tropical systems have an average life span of from 7-10 days, but may last over 2 weeks. This covers from the first development of a Tropical Disturbance through to when a Hurricane finally dissipates. ”
Currents at the Equator
North Equatorial Current (Westerly)
“ The North Equatorial Current is a significant Pacific and Atlantic Ocean current that flows east-to-west between about 10° north and 20° north. It is the southern side of a clockwise subtropical gyre. Despite its name, the North Equatorial Current is not connected to the equator. In both oceans, it is separated from the equatorial circulation by the Equatorial Countercurrent (also known as the North Equatorial Countercurrent), which flows eastward. The westward surface flow at the equator in both oceans is part of the South Equatorial Current. ”
Equatorial Counter Current (Easterly)
“ The Equatorial Counter Current is an eastward flowing, wind-driven current which extends to depths of 100-150m in the Atlantic, Indian, and Pacific Oceans. More often called the North Equatorial Countercurrent (NECC), this current flows west-to-east at about 3-10° North ”
South Equatorial Current (Westerly)
“ Ocean current in the Pacific, Atlantic, and Indian Ocean that flows east-to-west between the equator and about 20 degrees south. In the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans, it extends across the equator to about 5 degrees north. ”
We suspect that if all of the ocean and wind patterns, systems, storms, and currents of the world were traveling in a reverse manner to which they travel, that the Copernican Coriolis Effect proponents would instead be championing the Prevailing Winds and Ocean Currents as a proof of the Coriolis Effect and the rotation of the earth, while blissfully ignoring the hurricanes.